Shopify Password Reset Issue

Why Some Customers Do Not Have a “Legacy Account”

Introduction

In a Shopify project, an issue was identified where some existing customers were unable to reset their password even though:

  • The email address was valid
  • The customer profile existed in Shopify Admin
  • The customer had already placed multiple orders

However, when these customers tried to use the Forgot Password option, they received an error.
On further investigation, it was found that the affected customers did not have the label “Has a legacy account” in their Shopify profile.

This article explains:

  • The difference between legacy and non-legacy accounts
  • Why the issue occurs
  • How it was identified using screenshots
  • The exact solution implemented

Password Reset Page – Two Different Behaviors

Figure 1: Case 1
Figure 2: Case 2

 

Case 1 –  Customer Without a Legacy Account

Message shown: “Could not find customer”

Explanation

Even though the email exists in Shopify and the customer has already placed orders, the customer does not have a legacy (password-based) account. Because of this, Shopify does not treat the customer as a login-eligible user, and as a result, the password reset email is not sent.

Case 2 – Customer With a Legacy Account

Message shown: “If an account exists for this email, you’ll get a reset link.”

Explanation

The customer has a legacy account, and a password has already been created or activated for this account. Because the customer is recognized as a valid login user, Shopify successfully sends the password reset link.


Shopify Admin – Customer Profile Comparison

Figure 3: Profile A

Figure 4: Profile B



Customer Profile A – Legacy Account Missing

In this profile, the “Has a legacy account” label is not present. Even though the customer has placed orders and has a recorded total spend, the password reset does not work. This shows that having orders alone is not enough to create a legacy (password-based) account.

Customer Profile B – Legacy Account Present

In this profile, the customer details clearly display the label “Has a legacy account.” Since the account is fully activated and a password exists, the password reset works correctly. The customer is able to log in successfully using their email and password.


“Send Account Invite” Attempt and Limitation

Figure 5: Step 1

Figure 6: Step 2


Figure 7: Step 3


Figure 8: Step 4



When attempting to send an account invite from the customer profile using More actions → Send account invite, Shopify displays the message “Account invites are for legacy customer accounts.” This message indicates that Shopify allows account activation emails and password setup only for customers who already use the legacy (classic) customer account system. Customers who do not have a legacy account cannot receive activation or password setup emails, even if they exist in the system and have placed orders.


Why Some Customers Do Not Have a Legacy Account

One of the main reasons customers do not have a legacy account is that they were created programmatically through the Admin API, a custom wholesale flow, or draft orders. In these cases, the customer profile is created only to associate orders, and the password activation step is skipped. As a result, the customer exists in Shopify and has order history, but no legacy (password-based) account is created.

Another common reason is that Shopify allows orders to be placed without account registration, such as guest checkout or admin-created draft orders. When this happens, Shopify automatically creates a customer profile for tracking purposes, but no login credentials are generated. Since no password is created, the customer does not receive a legacy account.

In some stores, the newer Shopify customer accounts feature is enabled. This newer system uses passwordless, OTP-based login instead of traditional email-and-password authentication. When this feature is active, Shopify does not create legacy accounts, and the “Has a legacy account” label does not appear. Consequently, the password reset functionality does not work for these customers.

Another reason is that an account invite was never sent or accepted. A legacy account is created only after an invite is sent, the customer accepts it, and a password is set. If any of these steps are missing, the customer remains without a legacy account and cannot reset their password.

Customers who were imported via CSV or migrated from another platform may also lack a legacy account. For security reasons, Shopify does not import passwords. Even though the customer data and orders exist, the absence of a password means the legacy account flag is not created.


What Actually Creates a Legacy Account?

A customer is marked as “Has a legacy account” only when a complete password activation process has occurred. This includes sending an account invite, the customer accepting that invite, and setting a password at least once. Until all these steps are completed, Shopify treats the customer as a non-login customer, even if they have placed multiple orders.


Solution Implemented

To resolve this issue, classic (legacy) customer accounts were enabled in Shopify by navigating to Admin → Settings → Customer accounts and selecting the Classic customer accounts option. After enabling this setting, an account activation invite was sent to the affected customers from their profile page.

Once the customer received the activation email and set a password, their profile was automatically updated to show “Has a legacy account.” After activation, the forgot password option worked correctly, the reset link was delivered successfully, and the customer was able to log in using their email and password.


Final Conclusion

This issue was not caused by missing customer records or incorrect email addresses. The root cause was that the affected customers did not have a legacy (password-based) account. Shopify’s password reset and account invite features work only for legacy accounts. After enabling classic customer accounts and completing the account activation process, the issue was fully resolved and customers were able to log in and reset their passwords without any problems.

 


Comments